Follow us on Google News
Get the latest updates directly in your Google News feed
Duneis one of the most widely celebrated fantasy series in recent times. Being based on the 1965 series by Frank Herbert, the Denis Villeneuve adaptation has been a near-perfect masterpiece. Although, the emphasis on the ‘near’ in ‘near-perfect’ cannot be ignored. Much can be lost to the floors of the writers’ room when something is being adapted onto a different medium, especially when the source material was written almost eighty years ago.
A lot can change over such a huge period. Societies can become unrecognizable, and moral requirements can drastically shift. This is one of the biggest reasons why huge creative liberties are taken when adapting something so old.
Dune 2, PCVR, and Microsoft Flight Sim May Be the Best Argument for Immersive Media Crossovers Ever
Despite this, it is surprising to find out that the new version of the story has lesser representation than the original. It would seem that the very thing that Herbert was critiquing in his book, is what Villeneuve’s story has become.
Appreciation or Appropriation?
Frank Herbert’sDuneseries has a reputation for being difficult to adapt due to how complex its themes are and how well thought out the story is. This is why it was expected that whenDenis Villeneuvewas adapting it to the screen, some changes would be made to its story. However, what fans of the books did not expect was the evident lack of representation that the films would have of the culture of the people who laid the foundations of its story. ‘
The books have found a huge fanbase in the Middle Eastern or North African communities (MENA) due to the story being based on their cultures. The writer famously took inspiration from Islamic, Turkish, and Persian cultures for its world-building; with many names, languages, and characters being affected by this influence.
Unfortunately, as soon as the trailer for the first film came out, it was evident that all of these themes had been watered down and there was a very big, MENA-sized hole, missing from Villeneuve’s films.
Dune 2 Makes a Major Shift in Demographic as Sequel Eyes to Demolish Part One’s Box-Office Record in Style
DuneHas Turned Into The Very Thing Frank Herbert Detested
After watching the two films, many claimed the film to be white-washing the story. The original most beautifully shaped the lives of its characters based on a culture that is rarely seen in media in a positive light. Frank Herbert had been very vocal about how the Islamic culture had influenced his writing.
Quotes were often made from Islamic/Christian scripture. The Quran has been used to build the base for the religious beliefs in the world and many characters as shown to be religious in a similar manner.
Despite having their entire fictional world built on these cultures, they could not fully commit to them; shying away from the people who laid the foundations of their story. There are no Arabic actors in the main cast of either of the films and all the themes seem to have gotten lost in the translation from text to screen.
“There is no escape—we pay for the violence of our ancestors.”wrote Herbert inDune.
“Darth Maul is just Feyd Rautha”: Dune’s Success Has Sci-Fi Fanatics Lashing Out Against ‘Star Wars’ For Being a Poor Replica
What makes the entire situation all the worse is the fact that one of the biggest criticisms that Herbert reflected in the books was his disdain for white imperialism and the chaos it leaves behind. The anti-colonial message was a central theme for the entire story, which makes it extremely ironic that ‘white-washing’ is a criticism used towards an adaptation of the books.
Ananya Godboley
Senior Writer
Articles Published :2219
Ananya Godboley is a Senior Entertainment Writer at FandomWire, majorly focusing on TV shows, with over 2,000 articles published. She has been an entertainment journalist for the past two years. Currently pursuing an undergraduate degree in psychology from K.R. Mangalam University, Ananya also likes to fangirl as a full-time job. She covers news and analyses on anything from Rick and Morty to Hannibal and even Arcane. In between these lines, she also enjoys superheroes and Taylor Swift.A philosophy enthusiast, Ananya enjoys digging deeper into the media she consumes, trying to understand the root of her favorite characters' behavior.
More from Ananya Godboley
I’m 100% Sure Harley Quinn’s Funniest Superman Scene Is a Modern Family Homage
Ranked: Every Superhero Team Confirmed For Avengers: Doomsday vs RDJ’s Doctor Doom
Is The Rainmaker Based on a True Story? The Real-Life Inspiration Behind the USA Network Series
Recommended
The Batman 2: Is Zoë Kravitz Not In the Robert Pattinson Starring Sequel? Reports
17 Years Later, This Iron Man Scene Was the Darkest MCU Moment No One Realized
When Is Absolute Flash #6 Coming Out? Release Date, Plot Prediction & Everything We Know
‘The Serial Killer’s Apprentice’: How Dean Corll Was Murdered by His Own “Friend”
Is Apple TV+’s Carême Renewed for Season 2? Details Inside
Chris Pratt Thriller Dominates Global Streaming Amid Pro-RFK Jr Stance
Denis VilleneuveDune: Part Twofrank herbert
